Nicely-Nicely Johnson: Tommy Eyes Benny Southstreet: Nick Brogan Rusty Charlie: Noah Katz Sarah Brown: Alyssa Tschirgi Arvide Abernathy: Isabella Bonistalli Mission Band Members: Agatha: Kasey Clark Bertha: Karis Weisgerber Martha: Elizabeth Stroud Harry the Horse: Alayna Lightfield Lt. Brannigan: Megha Sharma Nathan Detroit: Sebastian Gisin Angie the Ox: Holden Levy Miss Adelaide: Caitlin Keller Sky Masterson: Kevin Key Mimi: Alayna Lightfield Hot M.C. Announcer: Jill McCarthy Hot Box Girls: Kaliegh Eckles, Leah Bahktia, Lauren Reutsh, Rachel George, Lindzee Loudon, Sophie LeClaire, Allie Kolp, Piper Berry, Jamie Cole, Megan Hull, and Julia Monthie General Cartwright: Amanda Jackson Big Jule: Max Nzone Gangsters: Liverlips Louie: Alejandro Flores Joey: Caroline Utz Society Max: Krista Schumm New Yorkers/Havana girls: Emily Groves, Alisha Mahja, Nicole Ouellette, Shelby Ransom, Mary Kate Shouse, Eden Stavrou, Michelle Weaver, and Danielle Wendt
